Recently one of the readers of this blog asked me a question about the Sabbath day and how it relates to Christians. This was a pretty involved question and I won't take the time to repeat all of the details here, but I gave it my best shot to put together a brief (but hopefully comprehensive) answer. Here's the gist of what I had to say about the Sabbath:
There are really a bunch of different positions on this issue.
First of all, you have the position which basically says that the Sabbath carries over from the Old Covenant to the New Covenant without being changed at all. Groups like the Seventh-Day Adventists, Seventh-Day Baptists, and some Messianic Jewish congregations hold to this position. They are really taking the commandment to keep the Sabbath more at face value than anyone else, because they keep it on Saturday (the seventh day). I wouldn't really say that they take the commandment entirely literally, though, because they usually won't put people in their congregations who break the Sabbath to death. Still, they are following this commandment pretty closely to the letter of the law. They would argue that since the commandment to keep the Sabbath is not part of the ceremonial or ritual laws of the Old Covenant (which Christ fulfilled and in the process did away with) and since it was never explicitly nullified, Christians should keep the Sabbath day as closely as possible. They would also argue that the Sabbath day is actually Saturday, since "Sabbath" literally means "the seventh day" in Hebrew. So for this group, to say that I am going to keep the Sabbath day on Sunday is like saying that I'm going to keep the fourth of July in the heart of winter. It is just a contradiction of terms to them.
Secondly, you have the position on the opposite end of the spectrum that holds that the Sabbath day isn't relevant for Christians at all, because we aren't under law, but under grace. People who hold this position would really emphasize statements that the apostle Paul made about the Christian's relationship to the law. On this basis, they would conclude that the Sabbath is now unimportant to keep because it was either fulfilled in Christ or just done away with altogether. So people with this perspective would still go to church on Sunday (or Saturday, or whenever they felt like it), but then they would have no problem going to work, a baseball game, wherever right after church. Most evangelical Christians in the United States fall into this category-not usually because they have thought through the issue and ended up here by conviction, but just because it is easier to fit this view into an already busy lifestyle.
Thirdly, you will also find the position that the law of the Sabbath has been carried over from the Old Covenant, but with some important modifications. The most important modification that Christians will put in here is that the Sabbath day is now on Sundays rather than Saturdays. For the guys who wrote the Westminster Confession of Faith, Sunday was the Christian Sabbath, and Christians are to refrain from all work, from all recreation, etc. The obvious reason for the change from Saturday to Sunday was because of the fact that Jesus rose from the dead on the first day of the week. These guys also probably wouldn't execute Sabbath-breakers, but they did try to pass laws in England to restrict the kinds of activities that people could do on the Sabbath. This is sometimes called "Christian Sabbatarianism"; the basic idea is that the Sabbath has been shifted from Saturday to Sunday.
The fourth and final big perspective is basically the position that the Sabbath is no longer a binding requirement on believers living under the New Covenant, but that it is still an important principle to follow that is based on the unchanging character of God (who took one day of rest out of seven). And-you guessed it!-this is my perspective, since I saved it until last. I believe that the commandment to keep the Sabbath is no longer binding upon believers living under the New Covenant. It is confusing to me why some Christians will preach grace time and time again, but then on a couple particular issues (the Sabbath and tithing) slip back into the mindset of using the law to issue commandments to other Christians about how to live. As Christians, we were not saved through keeping the law, and we will not remain saved by keeping the law! So why in the world would we take a new Christian who has had an encounter with God through the grace of Christ and start giving them a set of rules to follow? That seems like legalism through and through to me. It is dangerous and it is un-scriptural to say that 99% of the law of Moses was fulfilled in Christ, but that 1% is still remaining and active. If God wanted to do something like this, He definitely could have; but there is no reason to think as far as I can tell that He did.
So from my perspective, what do we do with the Sabbath? Since the laws God gave through Moses were all based on the unchanging nature and character of God, I'm definitely not willing to throw them away and say that they have nothing to teach me! Instead, I think that we need to try to find the unchanging principle behind all of the laws God gave through Moses, and wisely apply them to our own lives. Being under the New Covenant is no excuse for not living wisely; we should actually be living in a way that is wiser than people living under the Old Covenant! With the Sabbath, I believe that the principle we see is that it is wise and appropriate to set aside one day out of seven for rest and worshiping God. Could this be Saturday? Sure. Could it be Sunday? Why not. It could even be Thursday. Here's the key point-God gave us the principle of Sabbath-rest for our benefit, and He intended it to help us, not to hinder us. And since this is an issue of wisdom rather than law, I would never try to make someone feel guilty for not setting aside one day out of seven. I would try to help them see that this is wise counsel from a God who loves them, but I'm definitely not going to do what I've seen other people do in threatening the people of God with a curse if they don't keep the Sabbath. That is the farthest thing from grace that I can possibly imagine.
And I think it's the same with tithing. God gives us a principle to set aside one-tenth of all that we produce and give it to Him. Are we going to be cursed if we don't? I'm not willing to say that. But it is a scriptural principle, and one that we should pay attention to.
Maybe this will clear up some of the confusion regarding my position: I don't believe that Christians are obligated to keep the Ten Commandments. The Ten Commandments were part of the covenant that God made with the Israelites through Moses; we are not part of that covenant. So don't worry about keeping the Ten Commandments!
With that being said, I should probably back-track a little bit. Nine of the Ten Commandments are repeated in the New Testament, and it is obvious that Jesus and the apostles expected Christians to obey them (the Sabbath law being the only one never explicitly repeated in the New Testament). So it's not like we can live any way that we might want to live. So which is it: do we keep the Ten Commandments, or don't we?
I think this is what I would emphasize: we are not under the law of Moses any longer (Ten Commandments included), but we are not without a law. Instead of being under the law of Moses ('do this and you will live, don't do it and you will die'), we are under the "law of love" (love God with all you've got and love your neighbor like yourself). But then we've got to ask the question, "What does it look like to love God with all you've got, and what does it look like to love your neighbor like yourself?"
This is when the Old Covenant becomes helpful. Because God never changes, we can get a really good idea of what it means to love God and love others from looking at the law. We can't just say that the law is God's timeless will for all people at all places at all times; however. There are some laws that are entirely general and timeless ("Don't kill"), while there are other laws that are more specific and time-bound ("Don't allow an Amalekite to enter the assembly of the Lord", etc.). So we've got to discern the principle behind all of the laws God gave to His people, and then apply that same principle to our own lives.
So what do you think? Would you agree with what I said about Christians and the Sabbath, or disagree? Anything that you would add?


